I didnt say they weren't a band... and i really dont give a fuck about what labels look for to be honest. I don't think anyone should use that as a valid point when talking about the merits of a band etc... Besides why would a band like that obviously able to produce their own music even need to worry about what labels thought... theres bound to be a dozen electronica labels in the uk who would eat that up nicely
What I should have said is that I have seen better examples of that genre, and although they were polished I thought that the songs could have been better. I didn't really see many ideas in there... if you're gonna have a bash at that sort of semi industrial whatever you wanna call that sort of stuff... digital reznorism is it? then you're gonna need a heap of originality and production ideas... I didn't hear many... Saying that I couldn't hear much at all cos it took the engineer 15 minutes to get a line signal from the dudes laptop. LOL
Having said that I really liked the track where the guy played live keys instead of having them on the sequencer... That one had loads of texture... I seriously think if they had more live instruments in their arrangement these guys would rock. Another thing that confused me was that the guy was playing the rhythym guitar track live and the lead guitar was sync'd... surely it would "feel" better the other way round... maybe not, but I suppose I just would have done it different.
Clearly i was just taking the piss with my ever so unwitty kareoke comment.
I don't expect to get mega flamed cos I think if your band enters a botb then your opening yourself up to peoples opinions and commentary... I don't think im really being anything but constructively critical... with the exception of my earlier quip. Yes we can all be dickheads.